Dettmer v. Landon

Dettmer v. Landon
Dettmer v. Landon
Court United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
Full case name Herbert Daniel Dettmer v. Robert Landon, Director of Corrections
Date decided September 4, 1986
Citation(s) 799 F.2d 929 (4th Cir. 1986)
Judge(s) sitting John D. Butzner, Jr.
Case history
Prior action(s) Appeal from the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, at Alexandria.

Dettmer v. Landon, 799 F.2d 929 (4th Cir. 1986), is a court case in which the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit held that although Wicca was a religion, it was not a violation of the First Amendment to deny a prisoner access to ritual objects.

Contents

Facts

The plaintiff, Herbert Daniel Dettmer, was a Virginia prisoner, and a member of the School of Wicca. Dettmer desired access to ritual objects, including several varieties of knife, with which to practice Wicca rituals. Knives, of course, are not available to prisoners. When the state would not provide him these ritual objects, he sued Robert Landon, the Director of the Virginia Department of Corrections in federal court to get access to objects he claimed were necessary for his religious practice. The United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia decided in Dettmer's favor, finding that Wicca was a religion, rejecting the argument put forward by the Department of Correction that it was merely a "conglomeration" of occult practices. This decision was appealed to the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals, and was argued before the appellate court in April 1986.

Opinion of the Fourth Circuit

The Fourth Circuit, in a decision by Senior Circuit Judge John D. Butzner, Jr., affirmed the district court's ruling that Wicca was a religion, but vacated the injunction.

The appellate court considered but rejected the claims of the government about Wicca itself, which included that Wicca was a mere "conglomeration" of "various aspects of the occult, such as faith healing, self-hypnosis, tarot card reading, and spell casting, none of which would be considered religious practices standing alone,"[1] and that even if Dettmer's beliefs were religious, the rituals were not.

The conclusion of the Fourth Circuit was that the District court had found that Dettmer had a religious belief entitled to full First Amendment protections, but that he was not entitled to an injunction, since "[t]he decision to prohibit Dettmer from possessing the items that he sought did not discriminate against him because of his unconventional beliefs."

Importance of the case

While not entirely a victory for Dettmer, this was the first time Wicca was recognized by a court of law as a legitimate religion.

Notes and references



Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужна курсовая?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Landon — may refer to:Given name* Alfred Felix Landon Beeston * Charles Landon Knight * Landon (Planet of the Apes) * Landon Carter * Landon Carter Haynes, Sr. * Landon Cassill * Landon Cohen * Landon Curt Noll * Landon Donovan * Landon Garland * Landon… …   Wikipedia

  • Religious discrimination against Neopagans — Freedom of religion Concepts …   Wikipedia

  • Religion in United States prisons — articleissues article=y context=September 2007 unbalanced=August 2007Inmates incarcerated in the United States penal system practice a variety of religions. Their basic constitutional right to worship has been reinforced by decades of court… …   Wikipedia

  • Wicca — This article is about the duotheistic religion. For other uses, see Wicca (disambiguation). This pentacle, worn as a pendant, depicts a pentagram, or five pointed star, used as a symbol of Wicca by many adherents. Wicca (pronounced  …   Wikipedia

  • Church and School of Wicca — The Church and School of Wicca Formation 1968 Type New Religious Movement Headquarters Hinton, West Virginia, USA. Founders Gavin and Yvonne Frost The Church and School of Wicca was founded by Gavin Frost and Yvonne Frost in 1968. It was the …   Wikipedia

  • Charge of the Goddess — The Charge of the Goddess is a traditional inspirational text sometimes used in the neopagan religion of Wicca. Several versions exist, though they all have the same basic premise, that of a set of instructions given by a Great Goddess to her… …   Wikipedia

  • Dianic Wicca — The Wikipede edits Myriapoda. Dianic Witchcraft and Dianic Feminist Witchcraft,[1] is a tradition, or denomination, of the Neopagan religion of Wicca. It was founded by …   Wikipedia

  • Wheel of the Year — Sabbats redirects here. For other uses of sabbat or sabbath, see Sabbath (disambiguation). For Wheel of time, see Wheel of time (disambiguation). This article is about the modern Wiccan Sabbat. For the historical and legendary Witches Sabbath,… …   Wikipedia

  • Coven — This article is about covens in witchcraft. For the film, see Coven (movie). For the band, see Coven (band). For the village, see Coven, Staffordshire. A coven or covan is a name used to describe a gathering of witches or in some cases vampires.… …   Wikipedia

  • Starhawk — This article is about the pagan author and activist. For other uses, see Starhawk (disambiguation). Starhawk (born Miriam Simos on June 17, 1951) is an American writer and activist.[1] She is well known as a theorist of Paganism, and is one of… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”