Abraham–Minkowski controversy

Abraham–Minkowski controversy

The AbrahamMinkowski controversy is a physics debate concerning electromagnetic momentum within dielectric media. The preponderance of evidence in the debate suggests that the Abraham equation is correct,[1] but some investigators disagree.

Two equations exist describing momentum transfer between matter and electromagnetic fields.[2] Both seem to be supported by contradicting experimental data. The two existing equations were first suggested by Hermann Minkowski (1908)[3] and Max Abraham (1909), [4] [5] from which the controversy name derives.

Both define the momentum of an electromagnetic field permeating matter. Abraham's equation suggests that in materials through which light travels more slowly, electromagnetic fields should have lower momentum, while Minkowski suggests it should have a greater momentum. It was suggested that Abraham only accounted for the momentum of the electromagnetic fields, and his equation was an attempt to take into account the momentum of the material as well. More recent work suggests that this characterization is incorrect.[6]

At least one report has suggested Minkowski's formulation, if correct, would provide the physical base for a reactionless drive.[7] However, an independent review from the United States Air Force Academy concluded that there would be no expected net propulsive forces, and a NASA report determined that "The signal levels are not sufficiently above the noise as to be conclusive proof of a propulsive effect."[8]

The two equations for the momentum in a dielectric with refractive index n are:

  • The Minkowski version:
p=\frac {n h \nu}{c}
  • The Abraham version:
p=\frac {h \nu}{n c}

where h is the Planck constant, ν is the frequency of the light and c is the speed of light in vacuum.

A 2010 study suggested that both equations are correct, with the Abraham version being the kinetic momentum and the Minkowski version being the canonical momentum, and claims to explain the contradicting experimental results using this interpretation.[9]

Experimental evidence

In 2011, an optical experiment was performed to study this problem based on first principles. It tested the velocity-addition formula of light in a reversed Fizeau experiment. The result was that the light speed c= 299,792,458m/s in vacuum of Lorentz transformation should be replaced by c/n to describe electrodynamic phenomena in a dielectric medium [10] Consequently, the momentum of a photon in vacuum is p=E/c and the value should be p=E/(c/n)=nE/c in media, although it is not measured directly.[11] It is asserted, that this confirms Minkowski's formulation.

References

  1. ^ A. Feigel (16 Jan 2004). "Quantum vacuum contribution to the momentum of dielectric media". Physical Review Letters 92 (2): 020404. arXiv:physics/0304100. Bibcode 2004PhRvL..92b0404F. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.92.020404. 
  2. ^ Robert N. C. Pfeifer, Timo A. Nieminen, Norman R. Heckenberg, and Halina Rubinsztein-Dunlop (October–December 2007). "Colloquium: Momentum of an electromagnetic wave in dielectric media". Review of Modern Physics 79 (4): 1197. Bibcode 2007RvMP...79.1197P. doi:10.1103/RevModPhys.79.1197. http://www.hep.princeton.edu/~mcdonald/examples/EM/pfiefer_rmp_79_1197_07.pdf. 
  3. ^ Minkowski, Hermann (1908), "Die Grundgleichungen für die elektromagnetischen Vorgänge in bewegten Körpern", Nachrichten von der Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften zu Göttingen, Mathematisch-Physikalische Klasse: 53–111 
  4. ^ Abraham, Max (1909), "Zur Elektrodynamik bewegter Körper", Rendiconti del Circolo Matematico di Palermo 28: 1-28 
  5. ^ Abraham, Max (1910), "Sull'Elletrodinamica di Minkowski", Rendiconti del Circolo Matematico di Palermo 30: 33-46 
  6. ^ James Dacey (9 Jan 2009). "Experiment resolves century-old optics mystery". physicsworld.com. http://physicsworld.com/cws/article/news/37266. Retrieved 4 Mar 2010. 
  7. ^ Hector Hugo Brito (1999). "Propellantless Propulsion by Electromagnetic Inertia Manipulation: Theory and Experiment". In Space Technology and Applications International Forum – 1999, Mohamed S. El-Genk (editor). American Institute of Physics. ISBN 978-1-56396-846-4.
  8. ^ Marc G. Millis (2004). "Report on Prospects for Breakthrough Propulsion From Physics". In Proceedings 2004 NASA/DoD Conference on Evolvable Hardware. IEEE Computer Society. ISBN 0-7695-2145-2.
  9. ^ Barnett, Stephen (2010-02-07). "Resolution of the Abraham-Minkowski Dilemma". Phys. Rev. Lett. 104 (7): 070401. Bibcode 2010PhRvL.104g0401B. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.104.070401. PMID 20366861. 
  10. ^ Wang Zhong-Yue, Wang Pin-Yu, Xu Yan-Rong (2011). "Crucial experiment to resolve Abraham-Minkowski Controversy". Optik 122 (22): 1994–1996. doi:10.1016/j.ijleo.2010.12.018. 
  11. ^ Wang, Zhong-Yue. Graphene, neutrino mass and oscillation. arXiv:/0909.1856. 

External links


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Нужен реферат?

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Abraham-Minkowski controversy — The Abraham Minkowski controversy is a physics debate concerning electromagnetic momentum within dielectric media. The preponderance of evidence in the debate suggests that the Abraham equation is correct [Quantum vacuum contribution to the… …   Wikipedia

  • Minkowski — (Hebrew: מינקובסקי‎, Russian: Минковский) is a surname, and may refer to: Eugène Minkowski (1885 1972), French psychiatrist Hermann Minkowski (1864 1909) Russian born German mathematician and physicist, known for: Minkowski addition… …   Wikipedia

  • Hermann Minkowski — Infobox Scientist name = Hermann Minkowski |300px caption = birth date = birth date|1864|6|22|mf=y birth place = Aleksotas, Kaunas, Lithuania, Russian Empire death date = death date and age|1909|1|12|1864|6|22|mf=y death place = Göttingen,… …   Wikipedia

  • Refractive index — Refraction of light at the interface between two media. In optics the refractive index or index of refraction of a substance or medium is a measure of the speed of light in that medium. It is expressed as a ratio of the speed of light in vacuum… …   Wikipedia

  • Lorentz transformation — A visualisation of the Lorentz transformation (full animation). Only one space coordinate is considered. The thin solid lines crossing at right angles depict the time and distance coordinates of an observer at rest with respect to that frame; the …   Wikipedia

  • Electromagnetic stress-energy tensor — In physics, the electromagnetic stress energy tensor is the portion of the stress energy tensor due to the electromagnetic field. Definition In free space in SI units, the electromagnetic stress energy tensor is:T^{mu u} = frac{1}{mu 0} [ F^{mu… …   Wikipedia

  • Momentum — This article is about momentum in physics. For other uses, see Momentum (disambiguation). Classical mechanics Newton s Second Law …   Wikipedia

  • Reactionless drive — A reactionless drive (also known by many other names, such as an inertial propulsion engine, reactionless thruster, reactionless engine, bootstrap drive or inertia drive) is a fictional or theorized method of propulsion where thrust is generated… …   Wikipedia

  • Relativity priority dispute — Albert Einstein presented the theories of Special Relativity and General Relativity in groundbreaking publications that either contained no formal references to previous literature, or referred only to a small number of his predecessors for… …   Wikipedia

  • Criticism of relativity theory — Criticism of Albert Einstein s theory of relativity was mainly expressed in the early years after its publication on a scientific, pseudoscientific, philosophical, or ideological basis. Reasons for criticism were, for example, alternative… …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”