McCann v. United Kingdom

McCann v. United Kingdom

McCann and others v United Kingdom (21 ECHR 97 GC) is a legal case that was tried before the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) regarding a breach of Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights by the United Kingdom.

Facts

Intelligence suggested a team of known IRA members were planning a bombing in Gibraltar. One of the team was a known explosives expert whilst the others had been linked as well as convicted for various explosive and terrorist related activities. During surveillance, the team crossed the border from Spain with no resistance from the authorities and subsequently parked a car in a crowded place. In previous times, the IRA had employed remote control detonators and intelligence suggested the car was rigged with explosives whilst the suspects may have the remote detonator.

A team of highly trained SAS soldiers was sent to intercept and arrest them on conspiracy charges. The team, in accordance with their training, shot and killed the suspects which at the time was justified by the teams to be in response to the suspects reaching for what they believed where the detonators. The inquest into the shootings found no breach of Article 2 of the Gibraltar constitution. At the time of the shootings the suspects had neither a detonator nor any explosives. A car was however found registered under one of the suspects names which had been laced with explosive devices of 'ticking time bomb' type and not remote detonators. It appeared that the suspects were on a reconnaissance-mission and had parked their car to save a space for the actual car containing the explosives.

Findings

The case went to the ECHR. The court at the time had to consider whether the shooting was disproportionate to the aims to be achieved by the state in apprehending the suspects and defending the citizens of Gibraltar from unlawful violence. The court basically ruled that the actions of the soldiers at the time met the requirement of absolute necessity because they believed the suspects where reaching for detonators which intelligence and superiors had specifically warned them against. The Breach of Article 2 was found in the planning by the Authorities in that it was not 'strictly proportionate' to the objectives to be achieved; saving lives. Firstly, the court found a breach in the failure to arrest the suspects at the border so as to regard the life of both citizens and the suspects. Secondly, the court found that the Authorities did not consider the correctness of the intelligence (which turned out to be wrong) and, thirdly, the use of SAS soldiers - combat teams trained to shoot to kill - also amounted to a procedural failure in planning the mission which breached article 2.

The court rejected that the UK had specifically planned an execution mission and not an arrest mission.

Dissenting judges Ryssdal, Bernhardt, Thór Vilhjálmsson, Gölcüklü, Palm, Pekkanen, Sir John Freeland, Baka and Jambrek warned however against the benefits of hindsight, especially considering the situation at the time and the large number of innocent lives at risk.

External links


Wikimedia Foundation. 2010.

Игры ⚽ Поможем написать курсовую

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Daily Star (United Kingdom) — Daily Star Type Daily newspaper Format Tabloid Owner Richard Desmond …   Wikipedia

  • Culture of the United Kingdom — The Proms is an eight week summer season of daily orchestral classical music concerts, on the last night with some traditional patriotic music of the United Kingdom.[1][2] …   Wikipedia

  • List of MPs elected in the United Kingdom general election, 2010 — 2001–2005 (2001) 2005–2010 (2005) 2010– (2010) This is a list of Members of Parliament (MPs) elected to the House of Commons for the 55th Parliament of the United Kingdom at the 2010 general election. The list is arranged by constituency. New MPs …   Wikipedia

  • Human rights in the United Kingdom — The United Kingdom has a long and established tradition of avowed respect for its subjects human rights. At the same time, the UK, like many nations, has also had a history of both de jure and de facto racial and ethnic religious discrimination,… …   Wikipedia

  • MPs elected in the United Kingdom general election, 1852 — Changes 1852 *1852: Following the general election 48 MPs, elected as Liberals in Ireland, formed the Independent Irish Party. They included William Keogh (Athlone), John Sadleir (Carlow), John Ball (County Carlow), Sir Timothy O Brien, Bt… …   Wikipedia

  • 1975 in the United Kingdom — Events from the year 1975 in the United Kingdom.Incumbents*Monarch HM Queen Elizabeth II *Prime Minister Harold Wilson, Labour PartyEvents* 14 January Heiress Lesley Whittle (17), the daughter of late bus operator George Whittle (1905 1967), is… …   Wikipedia

  • 2009 United Nations Climate Change Conference — United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP15) Information Date: 7–18 December 2009 Location: Bella Center, Copenhagen, Denmark …   Wikipedia

  • Disappearance of Madeleine McCann — …   Wikipedia

  • Kerryn McCann — (born 2 May 1967) is an Australian athlete, and is one of Australia s most successful long distance runners.McCann was born in Bulli, New South Wales in 1967. She had an early interest in athletics, winning the New South Wales primary school… …   Wikipedia

  • Michael McCann (politician) — Michael McCann MP Member of Parliament for East Kilbride, Strathaven and Lesmahagow Incumbent Assumed office 6 May 2010 …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”